Mapping as a tool for predicting the risk of anthrax outbreaks in Northern Region of Ghana

Mapping as a tool for predicting the risk of anthrax outbreaks in Northern Region of Ghana

Ayamdooh Evans Nsoh^1,2,&, Ernest Kenu³, Eric Kofi Forson⁴, Edwin Afari², Samuel Sackey², Kofi Mensah Nyarko², Nathaniel Yebuah⁵

 

¹Veterinary Services Directorate Tamale, P.O. Box 241, Tamale, Northern Region, Ghana, ²Ghana Field Epidemiology and Laboratory Training Programme, Tamale, Northern Region, Ghana, ³University of Ghana, College of Health Sciences, School of Public Health, Accra, Ghana, ⁴Rudan Engineering Limited, 156 Atomic-Haatso Road, P.O. Box CT 828, Cantonments, Accra, Ghana, ⁵University of Ghana, School of Public Health, Accra, Ghana

 

 

^&Corresponding author
Ayamdooh Evans Nsoh, Ghana Field Epidemiology and Laboratory Training Programme, Tamale, Northern Region, Ghana

 

 

 

 

Anthrax is a soil-borne infectious disease that can present as peracute, acute, subacute or chronic febrile illness of all warm blooded animals including man. Bacillus anthracis, the causative agent of anthrax is a multihost pathogen affecting human, livestock and wildlife populations. Anthrax remains endemic in many African countries causing significant losses in domestic animal populations [1]. In Africa it has been reported in Cameroon [2], the Mago National Park Omo in Ethiopia [3], in Tanzania [4] and at the Selousa National Reserve in Tanzania [5], the Luangwa valley Zambia [6], the Kruger National Park in South Africa [7], Etosha National Park in Namibia [8]. West and Central Africa [9] have reported a new Bacillus anthracis found in wild chimpanzees and a gorilla. Anthrax outbreaks in Ghana have been reported since 1988 in the World Anthrax Data Site and impacts negatively on the economy of the livestock industry and public health. Anthrax is considered a major non-contagious, zoonotic disease since ancient times. Outbreaks in Northern Ghana have caused devastating economic effects in the livestock sector due to ban on livestock movement and slaughter and caused alarming public health concern [10]. Livestock production in northern Ghana is vital in providing food security and economic development to the people. The region holds 75% of the nation’s cattle, 54% sheep, 57% goats, 55% pigs. An estimated 89% of the farmers in Nnorthern Ghana rear livestock as well crops [11]. Over a third of the income of farm families is derived from livestock production [12]. However, livestock development in this area is challenged by diseases and high mortality. Northern region has been identified as an area with frequent Anthrax outbreaks in livestock [13] which results in high mortality, production and reproduction losses. The ecology and outbreaks pattern of Anthrax is not well known in Northern Ghana. In different parts of the world, anthrax cases have been directly associated with sudden rainfall and soil nutrient availability [14] as well as temperature [15]. These variables have been incorporated into GIS tools to map the suitability of the environment for B. anthracis spore survival, predict risk of outbreaks and identify hotspots in studies in regions such as Kazakhstan [16] and Saskatchewan [17]. Knowledge on the hotspots of anthrax within northern Ghana will help predict anthrax outbreaks leading to improvement in livestock production. The main objective of this work was to use routinely generated climatic data to build predictive risk maps to identify anthrax hotspot areas in Northern Region of Ghana.

 

 

Study design: we carried out a descriptive cross-sectional study which involved 10 year record review of rainfall, temperature from Meteorological service department and soil pH records from Soil Research institute covering the Northern part of Ghana. Anthrax outbreaks records in the Region from January 1, 2003 to December 31, 2012 were reviewed from district Veterinary offices.

 

Study sites: Northern Region of Ghana lies between longitude 1° 12” E and 3° 15” W and latitude 10° 30” N and 11° 10” N. The region has a single rainy season that begins in May and ends in October. The soil types are savannah Ochrosols. We used well trained and experienced field workers for the extraction of records on temperature and rainfall for the 10 year period to ensure quality. Two independent Meteorological officers cross checked rainfall and temperature records with the original files and all the necessary corrections were made. All Anthrax outbreaks coordinates which were not well recorded were retaken with the E-trex GARMIN Geographical Positioning System receiver.

 

Data analysis

 

We used Microsoft Excel for editing, validation, verification and descriptive data analysis to summarize the data. The monthly mean values of rainfall, temperature and soil pH were calculated per district for the study period. The descriptive summary of the outbreaks was done by pooling the respective monthly outbreaks data over the period under study to determine monthly occurrences. For seasonal analysis, the year was divided into Rainy and Dry seasons. For yearly trend analysis, the outbreaks of the respective years were added together. The district outbreak frequency was calculated as the number of outbreaks per district during the 10 years period. The geo-referenced data of outbreaks sites were used to generate distribution map of the spatial spread of the outbreaks using Arc GIS 10. We queried an existing shape file indicating the boundary of Ghana using ArcGIS software to carve out the boundary of the northern region. The mean values in excel were joined to their respective spatial district boundary with the help of the "join" tool in ArcGIS. The mean value of each district was concentrated in the centroid of the district. These values were interpolated using the kriging method in ArcGIS [18] to get values within the entire region. With the help of the reclassify tool in ArcGIS, each factor rainfall, temperature and soil pH was categorized into three classes (1, 2 and 3). Constant raster of values 0.5, 0.3 and 0.2 were created as weights for soil pH, rainfall and temperature respectively. The re-classified layers of soil pH, rainfall and temperature were multiplied by their respective constant raster value using the spatial analyst tool in Arc GIS. The product of the soil pH and its standard weight was added to the product of the rainfall and its standard weight. The sum of the two layers produced the Soil pH and Rainfall predictive map. The Soil pH and Rainfall predictive map was finally added to the product of the temperature and its standard weight to get the final predictive map. The goodness of fit of the model was assessed by overlaying the predictive map with the spatial distribution of Anthrax outbreaks in the study area. The final predictive map (Figure 1 B) was stratified for anthrax outbreaks surveillance considering suitability of environment for anthrax spore survival. Based on this, the region was divided into High risk areas as hot spots (stratum I), moderate risk areas as stratum II and the low risk area as stratum III.

 

 

In this study, within the 10-year period, there were 43 confirmed outbreaks. There were deaths of 131 cattle in 26 outbreaks, 44 sheep in 12 outbreaks, 15 goats in 4 outbreaks, 562 pigs in 2 outbreaks and 6 human deaths in 3 outbreaks. Twenty two people developed cutaneous anthrax (Table 1). The highest number of outbreaks occurred in 2011 with the least in 2009. There were no outbreaks in 2004 and 2003 (Figure 2A). The highest number of outbreaks occurred in April and the lowest in November (Figure 2B). Bunkpurugu-yunyoo, Savelugu-Nanton and Yendi experienced the highest number of outbreaks 5 (11.6%), Six out of twenty districts did not experience outbreaks during this period; Saboba-Chereponi, Karaga, Nanumba north and south and Tolon-Kumbungu. Some districts such as East Gonja, Saboba, Yendi, Nanumba North and South experienced very high rainfall and might have experienced flooding and erosions. Eight out of twenty districts; Bole, Sawla-Tuna-Kalba, Tolon-Kumbungu, West Gonja, Central Gonja, Tamale municipal, Savelugu-Nanton and Karaga experienced medium monthly mean rainfall. The rest of the 3 districts, East and West Mamprusi and Bunkpurugu-yunyoo experienced low rainfall (Figure 3B). Bole, Sawla-Tuna-Kalba, West and Central Gonja experienced low temperatures but Tolon-Kumbungu, Tamale municipal, East Gonja, Nanumba North and South, Zabzugu-Tatale, Saboba-Chereponi experienced medium temperatures of 27.9°C – 28.6°C. The other districts Gushiegu, Karaga and Savelugu-Nanton experienced high temperatures ranging from 28.7°C - 29.5°C and very high temperatures occurred in East and West Mamprusi to Bunkpurugu-yunyoo recording temperatures between 29.6°C-30.7°C. (Figure 3 A). Areas with low soil pH covers Bole, Central and West Gonja and the Southern part of East Gonja precisely Kpandai. The medium soil pH covers East Gonja, Tamale Municipal, Tolon-Kumbungu, and Sawla-Tuna-Kalba. The areas classified as high soil pH are West Mamprusi, East Mamprusi, Savelugu-Nanton, Yendi and Zabzugu-Tatale. The districts ranked very high soil pH are Bunkpurugu-yunyoo, Gushiegu, Karaga, and Saboba-Chereponi (Figure 1C). Based on the Kriged generated soil pH+Rainfall predictive map (Figure 1A) the region was divided into 4 classes by natural breaks and the final predictive map was divided into three stratums by risk: Stratum I (High risk area): East Mamprusi, Bunkpurugu-yunyoo, Gushiegu, Karaga, Yendi, Saboba-Chereponi, Tamale Municipal, East Gonja, Nanumba North and South and Zabzugu-Tatale. Stratum II (Medium Risk): West Mamprusi, Tolon-Kumbungu, Savelugu-Nanton, Kpandai and Sawla-Tuna-Kalba. Stratum III (Low Risk): West Gonja, Central Gonja and Bole. We generated validation map (Figure 1C) made up of the 10 years Anthrax outbreaks distribution map in the Northern Region.

 

 

The identification of hotspot areas is important for the control and eradication of anthrax. This study therefore clearly provides an anthrax spore suitability mapping and hotspot identification in an endemic area in Ghana. In total 43 outbreaks were recorded during the 10 years period of study with a peak in April and the highest in Bunkpurugu-yunyoo, Savelugu-Nanton, and Yendi and the highest outbreaks occurred in 2011. Our findings show a significance influence of seasonal variation on anthrax outbreak occurrences consistent with Chikerema [19]. The majority of the outbreaks occur at end of the dry season and early part of the rainy season which is associated with perennial shortage of livestock feed forcing animals to graze very low and animals are more likely to acquire the Anthrax spores. The records in a single outbreak, shows high pig mortality of 500 in Bole. This could be attributed to poor biosecurity measures which includes pigs being reared on free range and can easily unearth shallow buried anthrax carcasses [4]. Bole and Sawla-Tuna-Kalba are on the main route from Upper West where animals are being sold and transported to the southern sector. Similar studies carried out elsewhere [20] utilized multiple environmental variables including measures of temperature, precipitation, soil, and vegetation to establish a potential distribution model of B. anthracis in the United States based on the relationship between known occurrence data and environmental variables in proximity to the data. Outbreaks have been associated with heavy rains and flooding which are hypothesized to unearth spores [21]. East Mamprusi, Bunkpurugu-yunyoo, Gushiegu, Karaga, Yendi, Saboba-Chereponi were the hardest affected area during the August, 2007 floods in the country and that area remains prone to flood [22] The map produced (Figure 3 C) illustrated that with the soil pH districts such as East Mamprusi, Bunkpurugu-yunyoo, Gushiegu, Karaga, Yendi, Saboba-Chereponi were more suitable for the anthrax spore survival. Our soil pH finding is consistent with other works, that soils with pH above 6.1 to alkaline have been shown to be important geographical determinants of anthrax occurrence because of increased spore survival [15, 23]. Some work has found Seroprevalences in dogs consistently showing circulation of anthrax in areas where no human or livestock anthrax cases were reported but with high soil alkalinity [4].

Although the results of rainfall as a predictor seems a poor explanatory variable in other research work [24], contrary, our results established that the reoccurrence and outbreaks of Anthrax and rainfall have a well establish association. The soil pH and rainfall predictive map generated was stratified into three classes similar to [25]. Similar results has been documented in Canada [15] that anthrax outbreaks may be associated with alkaline soil pH and high moisture due to rainfall. Similar to work in Zimbabwe [19] we divided the region into high risk area (Stratum I) Medium risk area (Stratum II) and Low risk area (stratum III). Notably in stratum II are three districts that has not experienced any outbreak but once occurred the spore has the potential to survive for longer period due to the bioclimatic and the soil pH suitability for its survival.

 

 

In the light of these results, the kriged map has identified the following districts: East Mamprusi, Bunkpurugu-yunyoo, Gushiegu, Karaga, Yendi, Saboba-Chereponi, Tamale Municipal, East Gonja, Nanumba North and South and Zabzugu-Tatale as hot spot areas. The risk of Anthrax outbreak and reoccurrence is much higher than the rest of the districts.

 

 

The authors declare no competing interest.

 

 

Ayamdooh EN conceived and designed the study, designed data collections tools, collected data, analyzed and interpreted the data and drafted the manuscript. Ernest K revised article critically for intellectual content and final fine tuning. Eric Forson K designed study and expertise in spatial analysis and interpretation of data. Yebuah N contributed in design of study, critical contribution on analysis of data and review of manuscript. Afari E, Sackey S and Nyarko KM all contributed in the design and also critical revision of research work for content and manuscript write up. All authors have read and agreed to the final version of this manuscript and have equally contributed to its content and to the management of the case.

 

 

I wish to thank those in the field Dr. Kakari Agyeman, Dr. Yolanda Isabel Poveda Cajina, Veterinary Services staff, Tamale Metro, Meteorological Department staff, Northern region and the Head Soil Research Institute, Kwadaso.

 

 

Table 1: 2003-2012 climatic and anthrax outbreaks characteristics in Northern Region, Ghana

Figure 1: soil pH and rainfall predictive (A), final predictive map of anthrax outbreaks (B) and goodness of fit map of Anthrax outbreaks distribution

Figure 2: anthrax outbreaks in Northern Region of Ghana by years (A) and months (B), 2003 -2012

Figure 3: rainfall (A), temperature (B) and soil pH (C) distribution in Northern Region, Ghana, 2003-2012

 

 

1. Clegg SB, Turnbull PC, Foggin CM, Lindeque PM. Massive outbreak of anthrax in wildlife in the Malilangwe Wildlife Reserve, Zimbabwe. Veterinary Record. 2007 Jan 27; 160(4): 113-8. PubMed | Google Scholar


2. Pilo P, Rossano A, Bamamga H, Abdoulkadiri S, Perreten V, Frey J. Bovine Bacillus anthracis in Cameroon. Appllied Environmental Microbiology. 2011 Aug 15; 77(16): 5818-21. PubMed | Google Scholar


3. Shiferaw F, Abditcho S, Gopilo A, Laurenson MK. Anthrax outbreak in Mago National Park, southern Ethiopia. Veterinary Record. 2002 Mar 9; 150(10): 318-20. PubMed | Google Scholar


4. Hampson K, Lembo T, Bessell P, Auty H, Packer C, Halliday J et al. Predictability of anthrax infection in the Serengeti, Tanzania. J Appl Ecol. 2011 Jun 10; 48(6): 1333-1344. PubMed | Google Scholar


5. Gainer RS. Epizootiology of anthrax and Nyasa wildebeest in the Selous Game Reserve, Tanzania. Journal of Wildlife Diseases. 1987 Jan; 23(1): 175-8. PubMed | Google Scholar


6. Turnbull PC, Bell RH, Saigawa K, Munyenyembe FE, Mulenga CK, Makala LH. Anthrax in wildlife in the Luangwa Valley, Zambia. Veterinary Record. 1991 Apr 27; 128(17): 399-403. PubMed | Google Scholar


7. Pienaar UD. Epidemiology of anthrax in wild animals and the control of anthrax epizootics in the Kruger National Park, South Africa. Fed Proc. 1967 Sep; 26(5): 1496-502. PubMed | Google Scholar


8. Turnbull PC, Doganay M, Lindeque PM, Aygen B, McLaughlin J. Serology and anthrax in humans, livestock and Etosha National Park wildlife. Epidemiol Infect. 1992 Apr; 108(2): 299-313. PubMed | Google Scholar


9. Leendertz FH, Yumlu S, Pauli G, Boesch C, Couacy-Hymann E, Vigilant L et al. A new Bacillus anthracis found in wild chimpanzees and a gorilla from West and Central Africa. PLoS Pathology. 2006 Jan; 2(1): e8. PubMed | Google Scholar


10. Hanson EM. Veterinary Services Directorate, Ministry of Food and Agriculture Annual report. Accra, Ghana. 2010. Google Scholar


11. MOFA. Agriculture Statistics of Ghana, Facts and Figures. Accra, Ghana. 2011. Google Scholar


12. Karbo N & Bruce J. Contribution of Livestock to Household Food Security in Northern Ghana: Ghana Food Security Program. CIDA. 2000. Google Scholar


13. Opare C, Nsiire A, Awumbilla B, Akanmori BD. Human behavioural factors implicated in outbreaks of human anthrax in the Tamale municipality of northern Ghana. Acta Tropica. 2000; 76(1): 49-52. PubMed | Google Scholar


14. Hugh-Jones ME, De Vos V. Anthrax and wildlife. Rev Sci Tech. 2002 Aug; 21(2): 359-83. PubMed | Google Scholar


15. Dragon DC, Rennie RP. The ecology of anthrax spores: tough but not invincible. Canadian Veterinary Journal. 1995 May; 36(5): 295-301. PubMed | Google Scholar


16. Mullins J, Lukhnova L, Aikimbayev, A, Pazilov Y, Van Ert M, Blackburn JK. Ecological niche modelling of the Bacillus anthracis A1 a sub-lineage in Kazakhstan. BMC Ecol. 2011 Dec 12; 11: 32. PubMed | Google Scholar


17. Epp T, Argue C, Waldner C, Berke O. Spatial analysis of an anthrax outbreak in Saskatchewan, 2006. Canadian Veterinary Journal. 2010 Jul; 51(7): 743-8. PubMed | Google Scholar


18. ESRI. Geostatistical Analyst Tutorial. 2012. In: Environmental Systems Research Institute [Internet]. Redlands, CA, USA: [ 1-57]. Available from: http://webhelp.esri.com/arcgisdesktop/9.3/index.cfm?TopicName=Geostatistical_Analyst_Tutorial. Google Scholar


19. Chikerema SM, Pfukenyi DM, Matope G, Bhebhe E. Temporal and spatial distribution of cattle anthrax outbreaks in Zimbabwe between 1967 and 2006. Tropical Animal Health and Production. 2012 Jan; 44(1): 63-70. PubMed | Google Scholar


20. Blackburn JK, McNyset KM, Curtis A, Hugh-Jones ME. Modeling the geographic distribution of Bacillus anthracis, the causative agent of anthrax disease, for the contiguous United States using predictive ecological niche modeling. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2007 Dec; 77(6): 1103-10. PubMed | Google Scholar


21. Lewerin SS, Elvander M, Westermark T, Hartzell LN, Norstrom AK, Ehrs S et al. Anthrax outbreak in a Swedish beef cattle herd--1st case in 27 years: case report. Acta V et Scand. 2010 Feb 1; 52: 7. PubMed | Google Scholar


22. Forkuo EK. Flood Hazard Mapping using Aster Image data with GIS. International Journal of Geomatics and Geosciences. 2011; 1(4): 932-50. PubMed | Google Scholar


23. Hugh-Jones, Blackburn, J. The ecology of Bacillus anthracis. Molecular Aspects of Medicine. 2009 Dec;30(6): 356-67. PubMed | Google Scholar


24. Brandes AA, Brandl H. Anthrax in the canton of Zurich between 1878 and 2005. Schweizer Archiv fur Tierheilkunde. 2007 Jul; 149(7): 295-300. PubMed | Google Scholar


25. Cherkasskiy BL. A national register of historic and contemporary anthrax foci. Journal of Applied Microbiology. 1999 Aug; 87(2): 192-5. PubMed | Google Scholar