Factors associated with tuberculosis treatment failure in the Central East Health region of Burkina Faso
Adama Diallo1,&, Désiré Lucien Dahourou2, Ter Tiero Elias Dah2, Souleymane Tassembedo2, Romial Sawadogo3, Nicolas Meda2,4
1National Tuberculosis Control Program, Ouagadougou, Burkina Faso, 2Centre Muraz, Department of Clinical Research, Bobo-Dioulasso, Burkina Faso, 3Central East Health Regional Direction, Tenkodogo, Burkina Faso, 4University of Ouagadougou, Department of Public Health, Ouagadougou, Burkina Faso
Adama Diallo, National Tuberculosis Control Program, Ouagadougou, Burkina Faso
tuberculosis treatment failure results in increased risk of morbidity, drug resistance, transmission and mortality. There are few data about tuberculosis treatment outcomes in Burkina Faso. The current study investigated the factors associated with tuberculosis treatment failure in the central east health region of Burkina Faso.
we conducted a case-control study. All cases of pulmonary tuberculosis failing first-line treatment matched to those who were cured (controls) in the Central Eastern Region were sampled from January 2010 to December 2014. Predictors of treatment failure were determined using multiple conditional logistic regression.
a total of 381 patients with positive microscopic pulmonary tuberculosis were included. Of these 76 cases failed first-line treatment while 305 controls were cured. Weight loss between diagnosis and first sputum-smear examination was significantly associated with the tuberculosis treatment failure [aOR: 2.5, 95% CI: 1.3-4.7].
In addition, the delay from between treatment initiation to first sputum-smear examination, and high bacillary load at the first sputum-smear examination were significantly associated with treatment failure (p<0.001).
strengthening the relationship between health care services and local communities to improve the follow-up of tuberculosis patients, and improving adherence to tuberculosis treatment among tuberculosis patients with weight loss between treatment initiation and 2-month sputum-smear examination could be useful to reduce the risk of unsuccessful outcome.
Worldwide, Tuberculosis (TB) remains a major public health problem. In 2014, the World Health Organization (WHO) estimated that 28% of all TB cases were recorded from Africa although unevenly distributed throughout the region . Tuberculosis prevalence was estimated at 690 per 100 000 population with an incidence of 834 per 100,000 population in South Africa alone (the most affected country). Recently in Nigeria, the most affected West African country, prevalence and incidence of TB were estimated at 330 per 100 000 and 322 per 100 000 population . Worldwide, TB mortality in 2014 was estimated at 16 deaths per 100,000 population .
The incidence of tuberculosis in Burkina Faso and its mortality were estimated at 54 per 100 000 population and 12 per 100 000 population respectively . Burkina Faso began introducing over two decades ago strategies to control TB through a national program set up. The National TB Control Program adopted the Directly Observed Treatment Strategy (DOTS) which was replaced in 2006 by the Stop TB Strategy .
The main components of this strategy included short-term standardized treatment regimen, controlled anti-tuberculosis drug intake and prevention of anti-tuberculosis drugs resistance are . Despite the implementation of these strategies, tuberculosis treatment failure remains appreciably high. According to the national tuberculosis surveillance, the rate of tuberculosis treatment failure in Burkina Faso, was estimated at 5% and 4% in 2010 and 2014 respectively.
TB treatment failures most likely lead to increased morbidity and mortality . To say the least, 20.5% of previously treated TB cases (failure, relapse, resumption of treatment) were estimated to have developed multidrug-resistant TB (MDR-TB) (defined as resistance to at least isoniazid and rifampin) in 2013 .
Identifying factors associated with TB treatment failure will augment the smooth implementation of interventions curtailing anti-tuberculosis drug resistance as well as halting the tuberculosis transmission chain. Several studies have been carried out to identify the determinants of the TB treatment failure in Africa [4, 6, 7] however an all-inclusive data of factors associated with TB treatment failure is yet to be documented in Burkina Faso. The purpose of this study was to identify factors associated with bacteriologically confirmed pulmonary TB treatment failure in the central-eastern health region of Burkina Faso.
our study was conducted in the central-eastern health region of Burkina Faso. In 2014, the Central-Eastern health region composed of seven health districts (Tenkodogo, Koupéla, Pouytenga, Bittou, Ouargaye, Garango and Zabré), including 159 primary health-care and 6 secondary health care centres. Its population was estimated at 1,384,663. In that same year, the incidence of tuberculosis and relapse cases were 24 per 100,000 population .
Tuberculosis screening and management
patients suffering from cough which lasted over 14 days were suspected of pulmonary tuberculosis. They were subjected to sputum smear examinations at TB diagnosis and treatment health centre (HCT). The Ziehl-Neelsen's technique was used to identify an acid-fast bacillium in the sputum. Patients with 2 positive smears were labeled as new bacteriologically confirmed pulmonary TB patients. These patients were treated with first-line anti-tuberculosis treatment for six months regimen according to the national TB program guidelines (2 months of rifampicin (R), isoniazid (H), pyrazinamide (Z) and ethambutol (E), plus 4 months of rifampicin and isoniazid [2RHZE/4RH]) [2
After initiation of treatment, a follow-up was organized at the closest health care centre for patients. Daily intake of their anti-tuberculosis drugs was monitored by a health worker during the first two months of treatment.
HIV Rapid diagnosis testing was performed on all consenting TB patients. Conversely, HIV-positive patients were actively screened for TB during every medical visit. TB/HIV co-infected patients received cotrimoxazole as prophylaxis against opportunistic infections. These patients are eligible for antiretroviral treatment according to the national HIV program guidelines [9
Study design and population
we conducted a case-control study among bacteriologically confirmed pulmonary TB patients treated in the eastern-central health region of Burkina Faso from January 2010 to December 2014. Cases and controls were matched individually by age and sex. A case was defined as a patient with a new bacteriologically confirmed pulmonary TB aged more than 15 years with TB treatment failure. Treatment failure has been defined as a TB patient whose sputum smear examination is positive at month 5 or later during TB treatment. A control was a patient with a new bacteriologically confirmed pulmonary TB who successfully completed treatment (sputum-smear examination negative at 5-month and 6-month of treatment). To increase the power of our study, we matched each case to 4 controls. The controls were selected randomly in the same sex group and in age group-interval of 5 years.
the data were extracted from three registries at the regional tuberculosis diagnostic and treatment centres (TB case management registers, TB treatment and follow-up registers and HIV/TB co-infected treatment registries).
The demographics and parameters collected sampled from the registry for each patient included: age when the individual was diagnosed with TB, sex, occupation, distance from patient's home to the closest primary health facility, distance from patient's home to the closest TB diagnosis and treatment care facility, type of directly observed treatment (DOT) centre, weight at diagnosis, weight at 2-month sputum-smear examination, results of 2-month and 5-months sputum-smear examination, bacillary load at diagnosis and at 2-month sputum-smear examination, HIV status.
we described the characteristics of our study population. Categorical variables
were compared by Mac-Nemar χ² tests or the Cochran Mantel-Haenzel χ² test.
Quantitative variables were compared by the student t test for paired variables.
Conditional logistic regression was used to identify factors associated with
TB treatment failure. The outcome variable was "TB treatment failure" (case/control).
Independent variables associated with TB treatment failure at 30% threshold in
the univariate analysis were included in the multivariate analysis model. The
final model was obtained by a manual stepwise descending approach. A P-value < 0.05
was considered as significant. Multivariate analysis was adjusted on HIV status
to account for its potential confounding effect. All analysis were done with
R (version 3.3.1, 2016).
this study was authorized by the Central Eastern Regional Health Director who sent an information letter to all Medical District Officers and to the Director of the Regional referral hospital. The questionnaires did not mention patient's name to assure the anonymity of the patient.
Characteristics of the study population:
a total of 381 cases with bacteriologically confirmed pulmonary TB were included. Of these, 76 were cases of TB treatment failure and 305 were controls (cured) (Table 1). The median age of patients was 37 years [Interquartile Range (IQR): 29-50], 62.7% were men while 45.9% were farmers. Of all the sampled population, about 34% were housewives.
For the majority of the patients, the directly observed treatment phase took place at a closest primary health care facility (71.7%) (Table 1). This proportion was significantly higher in cases than in controls (73.7% vs 71.1%, p <0.01).
More than half of the patients had a weight increase between diagnosis and 2-month sputum-smear examination. This proportion was significantly higher in controls compared to cases (72.4% vs 48.4%, p <0.001). The bacillary density at the first smear control was significantly higher in cases than in controls (p<0.001) (Table 1 (suite)). HIV co-infection was significantly more prevalent in cases compared to controls (11.8% versus 8.9%, p <0.001).
: four variables were associated with TB treatment failure at the threshold of 30%. These variables were weight at diagnosis, change in patient weight between diagnosis and first sputum-smear examination, time from treatment initiation to first sputum-smear examination and bacillary load at first sputum-smear examination (Table 2
after adjusting for HIV co-infection, three variables were significantly associated with TB treatment failure; time from treatment initiation to first sputum-smear examination, change in patient between diagnosis and first bacillary control and bacillary load at first sputum-smear control (Table 3
).The weight loss between the diagnosis and the first sputum-smear examination was significantly associated with the TB treatment failure independently to other variables [aOR: 2.5, 95% CI: 1.3-4.7] (Table 3
). The bacillary load at first sputum-smear examination was significantly associated with the odds of TB treatment failure (p <0.001), with dose-response effect.
Our study reported that the delay between treatment initiation and first sputum-smear examination as well as weight loss between diagnosis and first sputum-smear examination were factors associated with first line pulmonary tuberculosis treatment failure. Furthermore, high bacillary load at the first sputum-smear examination was also associated with first line pulmonary tuberculosis treatment failure.
Weight was monitored at diagnosis and throughout the subsequent visits according to Burkina Faso's TB treatment guidelines. Our results showed that the patient's weight loss between the diagnosis and the first bacilloscopic examination increased the odds of treatment failure. This result was consistent with findings of previous studies conducted in others settings [10-12]. Recent studies showed an association between weight loss in the second month following treatment initiation and multidrug resistant TB [13, 14]. This result further expounds on the importance of using weight as a TB treatment monitoring indicator in resources limited settings where diagnosis tools are not always available in primary health care setting. Our study again confirms the importance of developing nutritional supplementation support for tuberculosis infected patients.
We noticed that sputum-smear positivity at 2-month was a factor associated with treatment failure. Patients with higher bacillary load at this examination were more likely to experience treatment failure [6
]. The sputum-smear examination is normally performed at the end of the 2nd
month of the anti-tuberculosis treatment [2
]. The first two months of tuberculosis treatment represent the initial phase of treatment. During this intensive treatment phase, the medication intake is supervised preferably by a health worker. It is during this phase that the smear examination is most often negative [18
]. In the context of Burkina Faso, sputum-smear positivity at 2-month could be explained by a non-systematic supervision of anti-tuberculous treatment which leads to low adherence to treatment. It could also be explained by the presence of a primary resistance to anti-tuberculosis drugs leading to a selection of multi-resistant bacilli. Atypical mycobacteria that are not sensitive to the first line regimen of TB drugs [2 (RHZE)/4 (RH)] might also explain this finding. In fact, sputum-smear examination with Ziehl-Neelsen technique can identify acid-fast bacilli (AFB). But, these AFB could be mycobacterium tuberculosis or atypical mycobacteria. Indeed, Zida et al reported a high incidence of atypical mycobacteria (11%) in patients with pulmonary tuberculosis with a positive bacillary microscopy in the Hauts-Bassins region in western Burkina Faso [19
]. Furthermore, we have established that TB patients who initiated treatment with high bacillary load at the 2-month sputum-smear examination were more likely to have treatment failure compared to those with lower bacillary load. High bacillary load also might be related to late diagnosis when patients are already at advanced stage in their disease. These findings highlight the importance to design and implement strategies to reduce the delay between TB symptoms onset and diagnosis. Patient should also be screened for atypical bacilli at diagnosis.
Our results showed that the delay between treatment initiation and the first
control was associated with TB treatment failure, patients with a delay in 2-month
sputum-smear examination being more likely to experience TB treatment failure.
Our results highlight follow-up challenges in TB patients included in this program.
These difficulties are, on one hand due to the irregularity of the access to
the smear-based follow-up examination by tuberculosis patients due to the low
capacity of laboratories in the region (scarcity of reagents, laboratory technicians
shortage) and on the other hand the poor application of the directly observed
treatment. These findings underlined the need to strengthen laboratory capacity
and to improve collaboration with community health workers to monitor treatment.
Unlike findings reported in some studies [20
ours showed that TB/HIV co-infection was not predictor of TB treatment failure.
Our results are consistent with those of other [7
This could be explained by a high rate of mortality rate prior to the 5th-month
sputum-smear examination among TB/HIV co-infected patients, resulting in a low
rate of inclusion of these cases in our study. For their HIV infection, TB/HIV
co-infected patients were followed up in a HIV treatment referral centre which
is not fully integrated with TB treatment centres. Thus, HIV/TB co-infected patients
had to travel long distances between TB management centre and antiretroviral
therapy centre. These pathways could lead to a lack of sputum-smear examination,
resulting to an under-reporting of TB treatment failure cases among the TB/HIV
co-infected patients. In addition, in this study, there were lot of missing data
on HIV status, which could increase the under-reporting of treatment failure
among these patients.
Strengths and limitations of the study
our study has some limitations. Data for treatment outcomes were available only for patients who underwent smear tests. Therefore, cases and controls are probably not representative of all cases of TB patients treated in the entire Central Eastern health region over the study period. Moreover, the retrospective nature of data collection was accompanied with large number of missing data. In addition, confounder variables such as discontinuation of treatment, antiretroviral therapy for TB/HIV co-infected patients, comorbidities (diabetes, hepatitis) could not be collected. These factors may influence adherence and therefore the effect of the TB treatment. Height was not reported and therefore it was impossible to study the association between the Body Mass Index (BMI) and TB treatment failure. Despite these limitations, our study is the first to use programmatic tuberculosis data from an overall health region in Burkina Faso to identify factors associated with TB treatment failure.
Weight loss from the initiation of TB treatment to the first sputum-smear examination, delay in 2-month sputum-smear examination and the high bacillary load at 2-months smear examination were determinants of first line anti-tuberculosis treatment failure. The Improvement of tuberculosis patient's outcomes in East Health Region of Burkina Faso requires strengthening collaborative strategies with community health workers in TB treatment monitoring. A strategy of systematic research for drugs resistant tuberculosis and non-mycobacterium tuberculosis in any new case of tuberculosis with a decrease in weight between the treatment initiation and the 2-month sputum-smear examination could improve treatment outcomes. For effective monitoring in co-infected patients, integration of tuberculosis and HIV care services is necessary. There is an urgent need to actively monitor cases of TB treatment failure in Burkina Faso in order to achieve the goals of the End-TB strategy by 2035.
What is known about this topic
- Lack or poor adherence to TB drugs predisposes patients to treatment failure.
What this study adds
- In the context of Burkina Faso, a weight loss after TB treatment initiation, delay in the 2-mont sputum-smear examination, and a high bacillary load at the 2-month sputum-smear examination were predictors of TB treatment failure. These factors could be identified early and reinforcement of treatment adherence could be implemented to improve TB treatment outcomes. There is an urgent need for the national tuberculosis control program to make available bacilloscopy examination tests according to the requirement of the scheduled protocol.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Adama Diallo designed the study, collected data, participated in the analysis and interpretation of data, and drafted the manuscript. Désiré Lucien Dahourou, Ter Tiero Elias Dah and Romial Sawadogo contributed to the design of the study and interpretation of data and revised the manuscript. Souleymane Tassembedo revised the manuscript. Nicolas Meda coordinated the study and contributed to the design of the study and interpretation of data. All authors approved the final version of manuscript.
The authors would like to thank all the staff of the health districts and health care facilities for their cooperation during data collection and Sandra Baffour-Awuah for her inputs in the English version.
1: sociodemographic, clinical and biological characteristics of the
study patients, Central Eastern region, Burkina Faso, 2010-2014
(N = 381)
Table 1 (suite): sociodemographic, clinical and biological characteristics of the study patients, Central Eastern Region, Burkina Faso, 2010-2014 (N = 381)
factors associated with tuberculosis treatment failure in the Central-Eastern
region, Burkina Faso, 2010-2014. Univariate analysis
factors associated with tuberculosis treatment failure in the Central-Eastern
region, Burkina Faso, 2010-2014. Univariate and multivariate analysis
- WHO. Global tuberculosis report 2015. Google Scholar
- PNT Burkina. Guide
technique de lutte contre la tuberculose. Edition 2008. Accessed on 05 February 2018.
- WHO. The Stop TB Strategy. Cited 2015 march 3. Accessed on 05 February 2018.
- Morsy AM, Zaher HH, Hassan MH, Shouman A. Predictors of treatment failure among tuberculosis patients under DOTS strategy in Egypt. East Mediterr Health J Rev Santé Méditerranée Orient Al-Majallah Al-sihhiyah Li-Sharq Al-Mutawassit. 2003; 9(4): 689-701. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Becerra MC, Freeman J, Bayona J, Shin SS, Kim JY, Furin JJ et al. Using treatment failure under effective directly observed short-course chemotherapy programs to identify patients with multidrug-resistant tuberculosis. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis. 2000; 4(2): 108-14. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Namukwaya E, Nakwagala F, Mulekya F, Mayanja-Kizza H, Mugerwa R. Predictors of treatment failure among pulmonary tuberculosis patients in Mulago hospital, Uganda. Afr Health Sci. 2011; 11(1): S105-S111. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Alobu I, Oshi DC, Oshi SN, Ukwaja KN. Profile and determinants of treatment failure among smear-positive pulmonary tuberculosis patients in Ebonyi, Southeastern Nigeria. Int J Mycobacteriology. juin 2014; 3(2): 127-31. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Institut national de la statistique et de la démographie (INSD). Annuaire
Statistique 2014. Institut national de la statistique et de la démographie (INSD), Burkina Faso. Cited 2017 jan 14. Accessed on 05 February 2018.
- PSSLS Burkina. Normes et Protocoles de prise en charge médicale des personnes vivant avec le Vih au Burkina Faso. Cited 2017 jan 14. Accessed on 05 February 2018.
- Krapp F, Véliz JC, Cornejo E, Gotuzzo E, Seas C. Bodyweight gain to predict treatment outcome in patients with pulmonary tuberculosis in Peru. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis. 2008; 12(10): 1153-9. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Hoa NB, Lauritsen JM, Rieder HL. Changes in body weight and tuberculosis treatment outcome in Viet Nam. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis. 2013; 17(1): 61-6. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Bernabe-Ortiz A, Carcamo CP, Sanchez JF, Rios J. Weight variation over time and its association with tuberculosis treatment outcome: a Longitudinal Analysis. PLOS ONE. 2011; 6(4): e18474. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Phan MN, Guy ES, Nickson RN, Kao CC. Predictors and patterns of weight gain during treatment for tuberculosis in the United States of America. Int J Infect Dis. 2016; 53: 1-5. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Frediani JK, Sanikidze E, Kipiani M, Tukvadze N, Hebbar G, Ramakrishnan U, et al. Macronutrient intake and body composition changes during anti-tuberculosis therapy in adults. Clin Nutr. 2016; 35(1): 205-12. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Oshi DC, Oshi SN, Alobu I, Ukwaja KN. Profile and treatment outcomes of tuberculosis in the elderly in southeastern Nigeria, 2011-2012. PloS One. 2014; 9(11): e111910. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Pefura-Yone EW, Kengne AP, Kuaban C. Non-conversion of sputum culture among patients with smear positive pulmonary tuberculosis in Cameroon: a prospective cohort study. BMC Infect Dis. 2014; 14: 138. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Chavez Pachas AM, Blank R, Smith Fawzi MC, Bayona J, Becerra MC, Mitnick CD. Identifying early treatment failure on Category I therapy for pulmonary tuberculosis in Lima Ciudad, Peru. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis. 2004; 8(1): 52-8. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Harries AD, Maher D, Graham S. TB/HIV: a clinical manual. World Health Organization. 2004; 213. Google Scholar
- Zida S, Tarnagda Z, Kaboré A, Zingué D, Hien H, Sanou A et al. Etat des lieux des mycobactérioses atypiques au Burkina Faso: résultats d'une enquête régionale. Pan Afr Med J. 2014 ; 17: 188. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Perriëns JH, Colebunders RL, Karahunga C, Willame J-C, Jeugmans J, Kaboto M et al. Increased Mortality and Tuberculosis Treatment Failure Rate among Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) Seropositive Compared with HIV Seronegative Patients with Pulmonary Tuberculosis Treated with « Standard » Chemotherapy in Kinshasa, Zaire. Am Rev Respir Dis. 1991; 144(4): 750-5. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Ukwaja KN, Ifebunandu NA, Osakwe PC, Alobu I. Tuberculosis treatment outcome and its determinants in a tertiary care setting in south-eastern Nigeria. Niger Postgrad Med J. 2013; 20(2): 125-9. PubMed | Google Scholar
- Endris M, Moges F, Belyhun Y, Woldehana E, Esmael A, Unakal C. Treatment outcome of tuberculosis patients at enfraz health centre, northwest ethiopia: a five-year retrospective study. Tuberc Res Treat. 2014; 2014: 726193. Google Scholar