Profile of dog bite victims in Jos Plateau State, Nigeria: a review of dog bite records (2006-2008)

Profile of dog bite victims in Jos Plateau State, Nigeria: a review of dog bite records (2006-2008)

 

Olaniran Alabi^1,&, Patrick Nguku¹, Silvester Chukwukere², Ayika Gaddo³, Peter Nsubuga⁴, Joliath Umoh⁵

 

¹Nigeria Field Epidemiology and Laboratory Training Program, Nigeria, ²National Veterinary Research Institute, Vom, Nigeria, ³Evangelical Churches of West Africa Clinic, Jos, Nigeria, ⁴Global Public Health Solutions, Decatur, Georgia, USA, ⁵Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, Nigeria

 

 

^&Corresponding author
Olaniran Alabi, Nigeria Field Epidemiology and Laboratory Training Program, Nigeria

 

 

 

 

Dog bites pose a major public threat both in developed and developing nations. In addition to the severe physical trauma and potentially permanent disfiguring wounds sustained after a dog attack, dog bite victims are often burned with emotional and psychological trauma [1-3]. Dog bites in humans are a public health problem worldwide and they expose victims to many potential zoonoses [4]. Globally millions of people are bitten by dogs; for example in 1994 it was estimated that over 4.7 million dog bites occurred annually in the United States (U.S.) and approximately 800,000 persons required medical care, 44 % of whom are <14 year old children[5]. There are reports of serious dog bites resulting in fatalities usually involving children, more than a dozen fatalities related to dog bites occur each year in several countries and most victims are children as reported in the United Kingdom, Belgium, the U.S. [5, 6], and the United Republic of Tanzania [7]. The most feared complication of dog bite is rabies, though not all dog bites result in rabies, however, in Africa and most developing countries where there are preponderance of unvaccinated dogs, every dog bite should be assessed for risk of rabies infection. This is because the pet dogs may have come in contact with a stray dog carrying rabies virus in the recent past. Rabies is a universal disease, estimated to be responsible for at least 55,000 human deaths annually, mainly in the developing countries of Africa and Asia [8, 9]. Rabies is acute, progressive and highly fatal (approximately 100% fatality). The incidence of human rabies is increasing in many countries; this is likely to be related in part to the rapid growth rate of dog populations, which in many parts of Africa exceeds that of human populations [9, 10]. Most of Africa and specially western and central African countries, notification of rabies is not mandatory, so epidemiological data are scarce [11]. This has resulted in inadequate control measures possibly due to under reporting, lack of follow up on victims of rabid dog bites, lack of data on the public health impact of the disease, and absence of programs for effective vaccination of dogs and control of stray dogs.

 

In Nigeria rabies is endemic, and dogs are the main reservoir of the virus [12], almost all the documented rabies cases have been associated with dog bites [13]. Dog bites are therefore an important public health issue [14]. There has been evidence that latent rabies exist--apparently healthy dogs were reported to have come down with rabies in Nigeria [15, 16]. During the period 2006 - 2008 there were reported increases in the number of confirmed rabies cases in dogs and the number of dog bite cases in most parts of the country. During this period there was also a reported problem of low vaccination coverage in dogs and lack of adequate information on the demographic profile of dog bite victims. There was also an absence of programs for the control of stray dogs and clinical records indicated that most human dog bite cases had incomplete doses of rabies post exposure prophylaxis (PEP). The indigenous people of Jos, Plateau state, in Central Nigeria are mainly farmers, with a very high dog population, partly due to the fact that most of the communities eat dog meat and from the records reviewed, the state reported the highest number of human dog bites cases and laboratory confirmed dog rabies during the period of "January, 2006" - "December, 2008". In March, 2009 we decided to conduct a study using dog bite and veterinary records to develop a profile of dog bite victims in order to recommend appropriate public health actions to the authorities of Plateau state that can protect the population at risk from dog bites and rabies.

 

 

Study site: We conducted the study in Jos, Plateau state, which is located in the central region of Nigeria. It is in the Guinea savannah zone with a population of over 3 million (according to the 2009, census). Jos had reported several dog bite cases to the Rabies Laboratory at the National Veterinary Research Institute, Vom, from 2006-2008.

 

Data collection: The standard practice is when a person is bitten by a dog that has no rabies vaccination history, such dog is killed and the head or brain is sent to the laboratory for rabies test. We used the dog brain specimen result register of the Rabies Laboratory of the National Veterinary Research Institute (NVRI). We reviewed records from "January, 2006" to "December, 2008" to obtain information about dog vaccination and ownership status and traced dog bite cases. We administered structured questionnaires to all persons who reported in the clinic for treatment of dog bite and could be traced. We also reviewed the records from Evangelical Churches of West Africa (ECWA) clinic from "January 2006" to "December, 2008" to collect information on age, sex, educational level, site of bite, and reason for bite, number of doses of PEP received and reasons for not completing the PEP. We selected this clinic because the NVRI laboratory records showed that all the bite victims during the period of study were advised to go there for the PEP.

 

Data analysis: Data from the study were entered into an Epi Info version 3.5.1 data base and we calculated frequencies, proportions, and percentages.

 

 

A total of 554 dog specimens were submitted to the Rabies Laboratory following a bite of a human victim, of those 383 (69.1%) tested positive for rabies. However, only 195 (50.9%) of the 383 bite victims linked to a positive dog specimen could be traced. Consequently, a total of 195 structured questionnaires were administered to bite victims. About three quarters (141 (73%)) of the victims were aged <16 years; 128 (66%) were males; and 94 (48%) had primary level education. The majority, (165 (85%))of the bites were on the hands and only about half, (106 (54%)) of the victims took complete PEP (Table 1). For those who did not complete PEP, 64 (54%) reported it was too expensive while 15 (17%) reported that the vaccine was not available, We also found that 182 (93%) of the biting dogs were not vaccinated. A quarter, (51 (26%)) of the dogs were unrestricted, 151 (74%) had owners, and 152 (78%) of the biting dogs were aged between 18-24 months. Most, (184 (94%)) of the bites were reportedly unprovoked. The year 2008 recorded the highest number of dog bites with two peaks in April and October. In 2006 the number of dog bite cases was lowest. For all years the numbers of dog bite cases recorded were lowest at the beginning of the year and dog bites increased during the last 3 months (October-December) of the year (Figure 1).

 

 

In our review of dog bite victims in Jos, Plateau State we found that male children <16 years in primary school were at greatest risk of being bitten by dogs. We also found a general increase in the number of dog bite cases towards the end of the year. Most of the bites were unprovoked and the bites were mainly on the hands. The biting dogs were adults, with owners, and the majority of the biting dogs were not vaccinated. Our findings of male children being at a greatest risk of dog bite are consistent with other reports of dog bites in children presenting to a pediatric emergency and trauma unit in the U.S. from 1995-1996 and in South Africa from 1991-2004 [3,9,17]. This could be because this age group may have limited experience or skills in recognizing a dog's body language and in perceiving hazardous situations that might trigger the occurrence of a biting incident [4]. Other reasons given were that children <15 years of age were more likely to provoke a dog or be playing with a dog. We also observed that most of the dog bites were on the hands, similar findings were reported in previous studies in Rome by Maragliano et al., in 2007 [18]. It is likely that this body region was used by the victims in protecting against dog attack [19]. However, studies in the U.S. and South Africa have reported that the common anatomical site for dog bite injuries in children >6 years is to the lower limbs [5, 20] this may be attributed to the short stature at this age.

 

Our results showed that about three quarters of the dog heads tested were positive for rabies virus and most of the bites were unprovoked. This findings supports documented classical clinical signs exhibited by rabid dogs. Our results showed a general increase in the number of dog bite cases towards the end of the year; this finding is not in agreement with the findings of other studies [4], where more dog bites were recorded during the middle of the year (June -July). The possible explanation for these findings could be that, in addition to cultural issues of dog eating as food this time coincides with the holiday period for schools and festive season with generally very high human traffic. At this time there is also an increase in the number of dogs purchased and brought home in anticipation for slaughter. This increases the chances of dog human contact as most of the biting dogs had owners and but were unrestricted. This study was limited by incomplete data on dog bite victims, because of the inadequate accompanying information on the suspected rabies dog brains that were submitted to the Rabies Laboratory for diagnosis, thus we could not link all the bite victims to rabies positive dog heads and this made it impossible to trace all the dog bite cases to find out the outcome of the bite. Additionally because the scope of the study was limited to one facility, we cannot generalize these findings to the whole of Plateau state.

 

 

The major conclusions from this study were that the profile dog bite victims were young males <16 years, dog bites were mostly on the hands, under unprovoked circumstances, by owned adult dogs which were unvaccinated. Almost half of bite victims did not complete PEP. Dog bites and dog rabies cases were highest towards the end of the year. We recommended that there should be strengthened collaboration between human and animal health authorities in rabies control, dog bite victims should be followed up to ensure completion of PEP in Plateau state. We also recommended that the health authorities should improve public health education on dangers of dog bites and the importance of dog vaccination, and responsible dog ownership, including restricted dog movements. The Government should ensure availability of vaccines at subsidized rates, intensify annual mass vaccination of dogs, remove stray/unrestricted dogs, and enforce leash laws. We believe these recommendations will go a long way in reducing dog bites and rabies in Plateau state and Nigeria. We recommend that dog bite victims should be followed up to ensure completion of PEP. There should be enforcement of regulations for licensing of dogs and responsible dog ownership. Government needs to ensure availability of vaccines and to intensify annual mass vaccination of dogs and remove unrestricted dogs.

 

 

The authors declare no competing interests.

 

 

Olaniran Alabi initiated, designed and carried out the study. Sylvester Chukwukere and Ayika Gaddo supported in the review of Veterinary and Clinical records respectively. Nguku Patrick, Umoh Joliath and Nsubuga Peter gave direction for the study, helped in the interpretation of data and approved the manuscript. All the authors have read and approved the final version of the manuscript.

 

 

All the support for the study is from Nigerian FELTP. The content is solely the responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of Nigerian FELTP.

 

 

Table 1: Profile of Dog Bite Victims in Jos, Plateau State from 2006-2008

Figure 1: Monthly Trend of Dog Bite Cases in Jos, Plateau State, Nigeria, 2006-2008

 

 

1. Peters V, Sottiaux M, Appelboom J, Kahn. A Posttraumatic stress disorder after dog bites in children. J Pediatr. 2004; (144):121-122. PubMed | Google Scholar


2. Schalamon J, Ainoedhofer H, Singer G, Petnehazy T, Mayr J, et al. Analysis of dog bites in children who are younger than 17 years. Pediatrics. 2006; (117): e374-e379. doi: 10.1542/peds.2005-1451. PubMed | Google Scholar


3. Keuster TD, Lamoureux J, Kahn A. Epidemiology of dog bites: A Belgian experience of canine behaviour and public health concerns. Vet J. 2006; 1725(3): 482-487. PubMed | Google Scholar


4. Dwyer, JP, Douglas, TS, Van AS, AB. Dog bite injuries in children -a review of data from a South African Paediatric trauma unit. South Africa Medical Journal. 2007; (97):597-600. PubMed | Google Scholar


5. Sacks JJ, Sinclair L, Gilchrist J, Golab GC, Lockwood R. Special Report Breeds of dogs involved in fatal human attacks in the United States between 1979 and 1998. 2000;217(6). Google Scholar


6. MMWR Morb Mortal. Dog-bite related fatalities- United States 1995-199 Wkly Rep. 1997; 46:463-467. PubMed | Google Scholar


7. Cleaveland, S, Fe'vre, EM, Kaare, M, Colemen, PG. Estimating human rabies mortality in the United Republic of Tanzania from Dog bite injuries. Bulletin World Health Organization. 2002; 80(4): 304-310. PubMed | Google Scholar


8. Matter HC, Wandeler a I, Neuenschwander BE, Harischandra LP, Meslin FX. Study of the dog population and the rabies control activities in the Mirigama area of Sri Lanka. Acta tropica. 2000 Mar 25;75(1):95-108. PubMed | Google Scholar


9. Kitala P, McDermott J, Kyule M, Gathuma J, Perry B, Wandeler A. Dog ecology and demography information to support the planning of rabies control in Machakos District, Kenya. Acta tropica. 2001 Mar 30;78(3):217-30. PubMed | Google Scholar


10. Cleaveland S. A dog rabies vaccination campaign in rural Africa: impact on the incidence of dog rabies and human dog-bite injuries. Vaccine. 2003 May;21(17-18):1965-73. PubMed | Google Scholar


11. Dodet B1; Africa Rabies Expert Bureau (AfroREB), Adjogoua EV, Aguemon AR, et al. Fighting rabies in Africa: the Africa Rabies Expert Bureau (AfroREB). Vaccine. 2008 Nov 25;26(50):6295-8. PubMed | Google Scholar


12. Adeiga, A, Audu, RA. Detection of rabies virus in saliva of apparently healthy dogs. Biomedical Letters. 1998; 54: 207-2. PubMed | Google Scholar


13. Warrell MJ, Warrell D a. Rabies and other lyssavirus diseases. Lancet. 2004 Mar 20;363(9413):959-69. PubMed | Google Scholar


14. Fagbemi, AH, Anosa VO, Ezebuiro EO. Hospital records of human rabies and antirabies prophylaxis in Nigeria from 1969-1978. Transaction of Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene. 1981; 73(6): 872-876. PubMed | Google Scholar


15. Anonnymous. Rabies. In Annual Report for Veterinary Department, Colony and Protectorate of Nigeria. 1932; 1: 6.


16. Anonymous. Rabies. In Annual Report of the Veterinary Department Colony and Protectorate of Nigeria. 1935; 1: 15-17.


17. Van Der Wijik J, Klasen HJ. Hondenbeten en de Ornstandigheden waar onda ze voorkomen. Nederlands Tijdschrift Geneeskunde. 1981; 125: 133-136. PubMed | Google Scholar


18. Managliana L, Ciccone L, Fantini C, Petrangeli C, Saporito G, et al. Biting Dogs in Rome (Italy). International Journal of Pest Management. 2007; 53 (4): 329-334. PubMed | Google Scholar


19. Palacio, J, Leon, M, Garcia-Belenguer, S. Aspects of epidemiologicos de las Mordeduras Caninas. Gaceta Sanitaria. 2005; 19(1): 50-58. PubMed | Google Scholar


20. Knobel DL, Cleaveland S, Coleman PG, Fèvre EM, Meltzer MI, Miranda MEG, et al. Re-evaluating the burden of rabies in Africa and Asia. Bull World Health Organ. 2005 May;83(5):360-8. PubMed | Google Scholar