Effect of placebo versus prophylactic postoperative amoxicillin on post-(adeno) tonsillectomy morbidity in Tanzanian children: a two-centre, double-blind randomized controlled non-inferiority trial

¹Department of Otolaryngology, Kilimanjaro Christian Medical Centre, 3010 Moshi, Tanzania, ²Department of Otolaryngology, Kilimanjaro Christian Medical University College, Kilimanjaro, Tanzania, ³Department of Medical Laboratory Sciences, Kilimanjaro Christian Medical University College, Moshi, Tanzania, ⁴Department of Paediatrics and Child Health, Kilimanjaro Christian Medical Centre, Moshi, Tanzania, ⁵Department of Pharmacy, Kilimanjaro Christian Medical Centre, Moshi, Tanzania, ⁶Department of Operating Rooms, Radboud Institute for Health Sciences, Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen, Netherlands, ⁷Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Radboud Institute for Health Sciences, Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen, Netherlands

^&Corresponding author
Denis Katundu, Department of Otolaryngology, Kilimanjaro Christian Medical Centre, 3010 Moshi, Tanzania

Introduction    

Antimicrobial resistance (AMR) has been on a rise as a result of over prescription and misuse of antibiotics in resource limited settings [1]. Due to limited stewardship and lack of strict guidelines for antibiotic prescription, AMR as a public health threat has to be addressed locally based on scientific evidence [2,3]. AMR not only imposes high costs of obtaining superior antibiotics to treat basic infections but also endangers lives of millions of people living in these settings [4]. Children are the most vulnerable population when it comes to antibiotics misuse and over prescription due to a number of reasons, especially in limited resource settings. Diarrhoea and respiratory infections are very common in this population and are often wrongly treated with antibiotics, regardless the etiology [5]. In addition, antimicrobial surgical prophylaxis is often given in resource limited settings even if there is no evidence of its effectiveness [4-8] Amoxicillin, amongst many antibiotics, has been one of the mostly over prescribed and overused essential drugs in Africa [9]. This results into cross resistance and increasing cost of acquiring superior antibiotics, at individual and population levels. Hence, antibiotic overuse drives the development and transmission of antimicrobial resistance [2, 6, 8, 10, 11]. Prophylactic surgical use of antibiotics has been well explained in a number of guidelines in different disciplines and practices. For (adeno)tonsillectomy ( (A)TE) however antibiotics have not been advocated in a recent Cochrane review and in other reviews. Post (A)TE) antibiotics have been reserved for special situations [12-18]. However, in other settings antibiotic prophylaxis is still used post (A)TE, this is based on local practices [19-23]. In Tanzania, no available evidence supports the need of prophylactic antibiotics following (A)TE despite amoxicillin being prescribed routinely following these surgeries. As (A)TE is a major childhood surgery globally as well as in Tanzania and post (A)TE morbidities may be fatal, care should be taken on addressing them [24-28]. At the same time these life threating complications are rare and most complications are less severe and the body can overcome them without permanent sequelae. On the other hand, prophylactic antibiotics may have side effects too, some of them being severe (e.g. anaphylactic shock). The present study compares the effect of placebo versus prophylactic amoxicillin on post-operative morbidity after (A)TE in Tanzanian children.

Methods     

Study design and participants: between January 13, 2019 and September 20, 2019, we recruited eligible children aged between 2 and 14 years electively scheduled for (A)TE to participate in a two-centre, double-blinded randomized placebo-controlled, non-inferiority trial. Indications being either recurrent tonsillitis as defined as 5 or more episodes of tonsillitis per year for at least 2 consecutive years and/or obstructive sleep apnoea due to adenotonsillar hypertrophy not responding to pharmacotherapy. We excluded all children scheduled for (A)TE due to other indications or with specific co-morbidities as mentioned in our protocol [29]. The study was performed at two referral centres in northern Tanzania. Ethical approval secured from each participating hospital´s ethical committee and National Institute of Medical Research. The trial was registered in the Pan African Clinical Trials Registry (identifier: PACTR201905466349317) and the trial protocol was previously published [29]. This trial was reported according to CONSORT 2010 guidelines [30].

Randomisation and masking: participants received either amoxicillin 50mg/kg body weight or placebo every eight hours for 5 days after surgery. A web-based randomization module was used in a 1:1 ratio and patients were randomized after obtaining written informed consent. Stratified randomization was accomplished using gender, age group (2-4 years, 5-8 years and 9-14 years), residence (rural or urban) and research centers as strata. All patients and health care professionals involved in the study, i.e. all other doctors at the ENT department of both hospitals as well as all nurses and microbiology staff involved were blinded to the randomization outcome. Only the pharmacist (HS) who had to provide the amoxicillin or placebo and the study supervisor, who was not involved in actual care of patients (NvH) had access to the randomization module.

Procedures: placebo was prepared under controlled environment by the study pharmacist. Capsules of amoxicillin were opened and active ingredients were replaced with the same amount of glucose powder. Similarly, for syrup amoxicillin, the syrup was replaced with same amount of sugar syrup maintaining bottle type, labelling and seal. All (A)TE were carried out under general anaesthesia with the use of orotracheal intubation. Procedures were performed by either residents or consultants. Technique used was based on the surgeon´s experience and preference, i.e. routine dissection, guillotine technique or electrodissection with a standardized 20-Watts monopolar technique. Both study arms were prescribed oral acetaminophen and ibuprofen post operatively. Children were kept for observation for 24-48 hours before discharged home. Following surgery, parents/caretakers were given a home-based questionnaire to be completed daily for 7 days. Body temperature and Wong-Baker? visual analogue pain scores were monitored by parents/caretakers every eight hours. Thermometers were provided. Haemorrhage, time until normal diet was resumed, time until normal activities were resumed and adverse events, such as a rash, vomiting, diarrhea and anaphylaxis were registered in the questionnaire. Children were scheduled for 2 outpatient visits at day 7 and 14 postoperatively. During each visit detailed information on progress were captured in a structured case report form. Complications, if any, were registered. A study dedicated mobile phone number was accessible to all study participants for 24 hours a day during the whole study period. Surface tonsillar swabs were obtained intraoperatively and on day 14 postoperative respectively for microbiology using Copan® Liquid Amies Elution Swab (ESwab, COPAN, Brescia, Italy). All swabs were immediately submitted to the microbiology research lab and processed according to the current international microbiology guidelines.

Outcomes: primary outcomes were postoperative haemorrhage, both major (defined as necessitating blood transfusion and/or return to theatre) as well as minor (defined as spitting of blood or blood stained saliva postoperative) during the first 14 days following surgery, and postoperative fever (defined as temperature greater than 38°C on 2 consecutive post-operative days or greater than 39°C on any postoperative day during the first 7 days following surgery) and the mean Wong-Baker^® visual analogue pain score during the first 7 days following surgery. Secondary outcomes included; number of days until normal diet was resumed, daily activities at the 5^th day following surgery as described by Linden et al. [31] and microbial recolonization of the tonsillar beds at 14 days post A (TE).

Statistical analysis: the primary objective was non-inferiority of placebo compared with amoxicillin for postoperative haemorrhage (at 14 days), postoperative fever (at 7 days), and pain (at 7 days). The non-inferiority margins were based on clinically meaningful changes. The non-inferiority margins for postoperative haemorrhage, postoperative fever, and pain, were set at 5%, 5%, and 1 point on the Wong-Baker? visual analogue pain scale, respectively. Sample size calculations were performed for each of the primary outcomes, the largest number of participants needed was used. Based on the latest Cochrane Review, 2.5% of all patients who undergo an elective tonsillectomy have a significant postoperative haemorrhage [32]. To show non-inferiority with 80% power, we calculated that 121 patients per treatment arm (242 in total) were required, assuming no difference in outcomes between placebo and amoxicillin, a 5% margin of non-inferiority, and 0.05 one-sided significance level. Assuming 10% dropout, we estimated that 270 randomly assigned patients per treatment group would be needed. Continuous variables were presented as means and standard deviation or median and interquartile range (IQR) if not normally distributed. Categorical data were presented as a number with percentage. Differences between the observed risks of events (for primary outcomes of bleeding and fever) between the placebo and antibiotics groups were calculated along with one-sided 95% confidence intervals. Absolute risks are also presented as it is important to be aware of the underlying risk of events. Differences in pain score between the two treatment arms were calculated as mean differences with one-sided 95% CIs, using Student´s t-tests. Secondary outcomes were analysed using chi-squared tests for categorical data (return to normal activities and microbial recolonization) or Wilcoxon rank-sum tests (days to return to normal diet) for continuous data. P-values < 0.05 were considered statistically significant. All analyses were done according to the intention-to-treat principle. Statistical analyses were performed using R version 3.6.1 (R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria).

Results     

During the study period 720 (A)TEs were performed, 270 children were enrolled after meeting the inclusion criteria. Informed consent was obtained from all parents. Subsequently, 136 and 134 children were randomly assigned to receive placebo or amoxicillin, respectively. Eight children were lost to follow-up in each arm by the 14^th day postoperative (Figure 1). Baseline characteristics of the trial participants are shown in Table 1. In both arms, the majority of children were urban inhabitants and in preschool age. The majority of participants was treated at KCMC (81.1%). Clinically, participants scored between Brodsky tonsil grade 2 and 4. In both arms, majority of surgeries were performed by residents, with electrodissection being the preferred technique. No major postoperative haemorrhage was registered throughout the study period. Minor haemorrhage was observed in 22 (17.5%) participants in the amoxicillin arm and in 19 (14.8%) participants in the placebo arm (risk difference (RD) -2.6% (95%CI -10.2 - 5.0) ; p_{non-inferiorty} = 0.045; Table 2). During the first 7 days following surgery, 8 (6.3%) participants in the amoxicillin arm and 4 (3.1%) participants in the placebo arm had fever (RD -3.2%, (95% CI -7.6 - 1.2); p_{non-inferiority} = 0.001; Table 2). The seven days average pain score was found to be similar in both groups 3.25 (SD 1.53) and 3.56 (SD 1.68) for amoxicillin and placebo groups respectively; mean difference 0.31 (95% CI -0.02-0.65); p_{non-inferiority}≤ 0.001.

Similarly, for secondary outcomes, no statistically significant differences were found between amoxicillin and placebo arms. On average, participants resumed diet on the second day in both arms (mean difference -0.19, 95% CI -0.68 - 0.29; p=0.43; Table 2). Five days after surgery the majority of the children had resumed normal daily activities (cried occasionally, made attempt to play and usual self together) in both arms. Main tonsillar surface and core colonizing pathogens were Staphylococcus aureus, and Streptococcus in both groups. No differences were found between both groups preoperatively. At 14 days postoperative the tonsillar fossa had been recolonised with the same bacteria as present preoperatively in 16.4% of the patients in the antibiotics group and 11.9% in the placebo group. In the majority of the other patients the tonsillar fossa was recolonised with other bacteria (Table 3). No statistical differences were found between the two groups. During the study period, none of the participants reported to have developed sepsis, possible side effects of antibiotic treatment or any other adverse events associated with study interventions in either arm.

Discussion     

To the best of our knowledge, the present study becomes the first largest trial to investigate the role of placebo versus post- (A)TE antibiotic in a Sub-Saharan African paediatric population. Likewise, in other resource limited settings, widespread and inappropriate use of antibiotics is not uncommon in Tanzania. Despite all other reasons for inappropriate antimicrobial prescription in our setting, surgical prophylaxis is projected as one among major contributors to AMR [4,7,33-35] In the present study, placebo was found to be non-inferior to antibiotics. Our findings on the effect of postoperative amoxicillin on post (A)TE morbidity are in accordance with those recently reported by Cochrane and other systematic reviews [17,32,36]. Some studies have reported even more haemorrhage in antibiotics arm. As might be perceived as early signs of infection, both post-operative fever and pain scores did not differ between study arms, as observed in other randomized controlled trials [15,18]. Although this study could not highlight on the possible side effects of prescribed antibiotics since none were found in our study, not giving amoxicillin has a positive protective advantage against the side effects which might be severe [19,36,37]. As with any study our trial has some limitations and shortcomings. Some of our outcomes were either self-reported or self-measured. We reckon that this cannot have resulted in missing any major haemorrhage. Due to our definition of minor haemorrhage (spitting of blood or blood-stained saliva postoperative) there may have been some over-reporting. Temperature was measured by the parents using a thermometer provided by the study. Here, some under-reporting may have occurred due to wrong technique of measuring the temperature despite proper instructions. We advocate that all these possible limitations will have been divided equally over both groups due to randomisation and therefore will not have affected study outcome.

Conclusion     

This study shows that placebo is non-inferior to amoxicillin for post (A)TE morbidities. Therefore, we advise against the use of prophylactic antibiotics in children undergoing (A)TE. This will hopefully contribute to reduction of AMR and more awareness of proper prophylactic antibiotic usage. Understanding the side effects, cost and availability of antibiotics and the burden of AMR that is further increased by over and misuse of postoperative antibiotics, their prescription during (A)TE is discouraged even in resources limited settings.

Competing interests     

The authors declare no competing interests.

Authors' contributions     

Denis Katundu and Niels van Heerbeek designed the study and drafted the manuscript. Gerjon Hannink analysed the data. All authors verified the data and analysis. Denis Katundu, performed inclusion and follow-up of all patients and participated in surgical procedures. Desderius Chussi was the local supervisor, he also participated in surgical procedures. Balthazar Nyombi and Hadija Semvua were responsible for microbiology and trial medication respectively. Gerjon Hannink, Balthazar Nyombi, Hadija Semvua, Desderius Chussi, and Rune Philemon co-authored the manuscript. All authors have read and approved the final version of the manuscript.

Acknowledgments     

We thank all the participants and staff from all the centres participating in this trial. Special thanks to Hans Groenewoud for his dedication in preparing and maintaining trial randomization module, study centers ethical committee and Susana Kawedi (KCMC, ENT operating rooms nurse in-charge). Trial was non-industry funded. All costs are mainly covered by a grant from the Radboudumc Revolving Research Fund (R3Fund), i.e., a scholarship program for PhD candidates from low-middle income countries.

Tables and figure     

Table 1: baseline characteristics

Table 2: primary outcomes

Table 3: secondary outcomes

Figure 1: flow diagram of the trial profile

References